How to Decide Whether to Repair or Replace Your Damaged Faucet
How to Decide Whether to Repair or Replace Your Damaged Faucet
A leaky or malfunctioning faucet may seem like a minor annoyance, but the damage it can cause over time is no small matter. A dripping faucet alone can waste hundreds of gallons of water annually, driving up your utility bills and potentially leading to water damage, mold growth, or even electrical hazards in nearby areas.
Knowing whether to repair or replace your faucet comes down to the type of damage, the age of the fixture, and the cost-effectiveness of either solution. If you're unsure where to start, here’s a breakdown of what to look for and when to take action.
Signs Your Faucet May Be Damaged
Not every faucet issue requires replacement, but here are some warning signs that indicate you should schedule an inspection:
Constant dripping
A faucet that drips continually, even when fully closed, is typically caused by high water pressure, a worn valve, or a damaged O-ring.
Irregular or spitting water flow
If the stream is inconsistent or splashes in multiple directions, internal components may be cracked or clogged.
Squeaking or stiff handles
Faucet handles should turn smoothly. If they squeak or feel stiff, it could be a sign of wear, mineral buildup, or internal part failure.
When It’s Better to Repair Your Faucet
In many cases, a faucet repair is simple, affordable, and effective. A few situations where repair makes the most sense include:
The faucet type allows easy part replacement
Ball faucets, cartridge faucets, and compression faucets often have replaceable internal parts. If the damage is limited to a washer, O-ring, or handle, a quick repair may restore full functionality.
You have a high-end or designer faucet
Luxury fixtures can be costly to replace. When your faucet is part of a custom kitchen or bathroom design, repairing it can preserve the aesthetic and save you money.
The faucet has a minor issue
A slow drip or squeaky handle is often solved by tightening components or applying plumber’s grease. If there’s no significant structural damage, a repair is likely sufficient.
You want to avoid unnecessary waste
If your faucet is relatively new or has only had one or two minor issues, repairing it is the more sustainable option.
When It’s Time to Replace the Faucet
Faucets wear down with age, hard water buildup, and repeated use. While repairs are effective in many cases, replacement is the smarter move when:
The faucet is over 15 years old
Even with good maintenance, most faucets are built to last between 10 and 20 years. Beyond that, efficiency drops and parts may be harder to find.
You’re dealing with frequent repairs
If you’re constantly calling for faucet repairs, the ongoing cost may exceed the price of a new fixture.
You want better water efficiency
Older faucets can use as much as 3 to 5 gallons per minute. Today’s water-saving models are built to run at 1.5 to 2.5 gpm, cutting down on waste and lowering your bills.
Your sink or countertop is being replaced
If the surface around the faucet is damaged or being remodeled, it's often easiest to install a new faucet at the same time, especially if finishes or mount sizes are changing.
Why Damaged Faucets Shouldn’t Be Ignored
A faulty faucet can be more than a daily inconvenience. Over time, it can:
- Lead to mold or rot beneath sinks or behind walls
- Increase your utility bills with wasted water
- Cause damage to surrounding surfaces like countertops and cabinetry
- Reduce your home’s value if visible water damage occurs
A licensed plumber can inspect your faucet, assess the issue, and recommend the most cost-effective and long-lasting solution.